Row Over Services: Will Examine If Parliament Can Abrogate C

Card image

Row Over Services: Will Examine If Parliament Can Abrogate Constitutional Principles Of Governance For Delhi, Says Supreme Court

By Admin |

The Supreme Court has said a five-judge constitution bench will examine whether Parliament can “abrogate the constitutional principles of governance” for the Delhi government by making a law to take away its control over services. The Centre recently issued an ordinance on the Delhi services matter by exercising its powers under Article 239-AA, a special provision in the Constitution pertaining to the national capital.

The top court, which on Thursday referred to a constitution bench the :
(i) What are the contours of the power of Parliament to enact a law under Article 239-AA(7); and (ii) Whether Parliament in the exercise of its power under Article 239-AA(7) can abrogate the constitutional principles of governance for the National Capital Territory of Delhi (NCTD),” said the order passed by a bench of Chief Justice D Y Chandrachud and justices P S Narasimha and Manoj Misra.

A 10-page order, penned by the CJI, said there were two preliminary issues which arose for the consideration by a larger bench.

 

“The first is on the import of Section 3A (of the ordinance). Section 3A removes Entry 41 (services) of List II (State List) from the legislative competence of the NCTD. On the exclusion of Entry 41 from the NCTD’s legislative power, the government of the NCTD ceases to have executive power over services because executive power is co-terminus with the legislative power,” the order said.

The issue, therefore, is whether a law could completely remove Delhi government’s executive power over services, it said, adding that the aspect of services under Entry 41 was also “interconnected with the validity of Section 3A” of the ordinance.

 

While referring the Delhi government’s plea to the constitution bench, it had rejected the vehement submission of the city dispensation that there was no need for referring the matter to a constitution bench as it will “paralyse the whole system” during its pendency.

On Thursday, the bench raised a  raised a query with regard to the ordinance and said it took away the control of services from the control of the Delhi government.

The Constitution excludes three entries of List II (State List) related to police, law and order and land from the control of the Delhi government, it said.

 
“What you (Centre) have effectively done is that the Constitution says barring three entries, Delhi legislative assembly has the power. But, the ordinance takes away Entry 41 (services) (of the List II) also from the power. That is the effect of Section 3A of the ordinance,” the bench said.
The bench had recently issued notices to the Centre and the Delhi lieutenant governor on the plea while refusing to grant an interim stay on the ordinance on control over services in the national capial.

 

Article 239AA deals with special provisions with respect to Delhi in the Constitution and its sub-article 7 says, “Parliament may, by law, make provisions for giving effect to, or supplementing the provisions contained in the foregoing clauses and for all matters incidental or consequential thereto.”

It also says any such law made under the article “shall not be deemed to be an amendment of this Constitution for the purposes of Article 368 notwithstanding that it contains any provision which amends or has the effect of amending, this Constitution.”

The Centre had on May 19 promulgated the Government of National Capital Territory of Delhi (Amendment) Ordinance, 2023, to create an authority for transfer and posting of Group-A officers in Delhi.
Source
Latest News Latest Supreme Court
Search Here

Latest Posts

Card image

Stop Misleading Advertisements Will Impose Rs Crore Cost On Every Product Claiming False Cure...

The Supreme Court on Tuesday November reprimanded the Patanjali Ayurved for continuing to publish misleading claims and advertisements against modern systems of medicine While considering a petition filed by the Indian Medical Association against misleading advertisements the bench comprising...

Card image

Personal Law Or Statute Can't Override Welfare Of Child' Supreme Court Grants Custody Of...

The Supreme Court while granting custody of a minor child to the her aunt despite opposition from the father held that the personal law or statute couldn't override the welfare of the child while deciding the custody of the child...

Card image

SC refuses to entertain plea for survey of Krishna Janmabhoomi-Shahi Idgah premises...

The Supreme Court Friday refused to entertain a plea by 'Shri Krishna Janambhoomi Mukti Nirman Trust' seeking a survey of the Janmabhoomi-Shahi Idgah mosque premises in Mathura to determine whether it was built on a pre-existing Hindu temple The apex...

Card image

Why Is CARA Delaying Adoption Process Supreme Court Calls For Prompt Action To Benefit...

The Supreme Court on Friday raised serious concerns over the delays in the adoption process and the potential impact on both aspiring parents and children in need of loving homes The remarks came from a bench comprising CJI DY...

Card image

Navigating the Complexities of Corporate Commercial Laws Key Considerations for Businesses...

In today's dynamic business landscape understanding and complying with corporate and commercial laws are paramount for organizations aiming to thrive and expand From formation and governance to contractual relationships and regulatory compliance adherence to legal frameworks is essential for maintaining...

Card image

SC Ruling On User Development Fee Provides Guidance For GST Tax On Royalty...

The nbsp SC nbsp had held that nbsp UDF nbsp collected by the nbsp DIAL nbsp is in the nature of statutory levy and the same would not be taken as consideration against any services A recent judgment by the...

EOS Chambers of Law

Speak With Our
Experts Today!

Get a Appointment
EOS Chambers of Law