The Supreme Court in India has started allowing sign language interpretation for hearing impaired lawyers, demonstrating that not everything needs to be spoken aloud in court. In a recent case, a deaf advocate was permitted to virtually argue with the help of a sign language interpreter.
NEW DELHI: The Supreme Court has begun allowing case proceedings to be translated through sign language for hearing impaired lawyers, sending a message that everything need not be spoken aloud in courts.
On Friday, advocate-on-record Sanchita Ain made an unusual request to a CJI DY Chandrachud-led bench — deaf advocate Sarah Sunny be permitted to virtually argue a case concerning rights of Persons with Disability (PwD) with the help of sign languageinterpreter Saurav Roychowdhury. The CJI immediately agreed and the virtual court supervisor opened online hearing windows for Sarah and Saurav.
The loud world of courts got translated silently through sign language for the high-spirited hearing impaired advocate. Her case was listed at serial no. 37, but the bench permitted the duo to remain logged in for the day’s proceedings.
Next few minutes were an eye-opening experience for many who watched the duo’s deliberations. At first, it was the interpreter who through rapid hand and finger movements conveyed to Sarah the proceedings before the court and who said what. As the CJI-led bench made a rapid fire round of listing of cases mentioned for urgent listing, solicitor general Tushar Mehta said, “The speed with which the interpreter conveyed the court proceedings to the lawyer was amazing!” the CJI agreed.
When the case, a petition filed by Javed Abidi Foundation, was called out, the Sarah-Saurav duo did a rapid tango of silent sign language-converted-to-arguments. When the CJI-led bench turned to the Centre for an answer, additional solicitor general Aishwarya Bhati said, “An updated status report shall be filed by the Union government so that the petition can be finally disposed of on the next occasion.”
On Monday, founder president of Bhumika Trust Jayant Singh Raghav, who is blind, argued for implementation of the proviso to Section 24 of the Rights of PwD Act, which said “assistance to the persons with disabilities under such (welfare) schemes and programmes shall be at 25% higher than the similar schemes applicable to others.” The has sought response from the Union government. For visually impaired lawyers, advocate Santosh Kumar Rungta remains the living example of “where there is a will there’s a way”. He has not allowed blindness to impede his case presentation skills and was deservedly designated ‘senior advocate’ by the Delhi high court in 2011 — he’s the first visually impaired person to get the coveted senior lawyer gown.
Last year, the CJI had enlisted his services to audit the accessibility of persons with disability to the SC website. Rungta was instrumental in getting a direction from the SC in 2013 for implementation of 3% reservation for differently-abled persons in government jobs. Justice Chandrachud had been a votary of equal opportunity for PwD and his various orders and judgments are a testament to this endeavour.
The seven-judge Constitution bench of the Supreme Court said it disagreed with the judgment in PV Narasimha and the judgment in PV Narasimha which grants immunity to legislators for allegedly bribery for casting a vote or speech has ldquo wide...
The CJI said the law didn't preclude unmarried couples from adopting Chief Justice of India DY Chandrachud while announcing his verdict on a clutch of petitions demanding legal status to same-sex marriages today struck down the Central Adoption Resource Authority's...
The Supreme Court ruled that Aadhaar the ambitious public scheme that uses biometric data to generate unique identification numbers for citizens is constitutionally valid but with conditions Here are the key takeaways from today rsquo s verdict Read More nbsp...
Chief Justice of India D Y Chandrachudrecently spoke on how no technology is neutral and how it can reflect human values when deployed in the real world The CJI spoke on how one must ponder the human and societal values...
The Supreme Court has held that if an Indian Entity rsquo s Establishment is operating in Oman and has a lsquo Permanent Establishment rsquo status under Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement ldquo DTAA rdquo then the dividend income received by the...
Dear community In the ever-evolving landscape of dispute resolution the demand for faster and more efficient solutions is on the rise As businesses and individuals seek alternatives to protracted litigation arbitration has emerged as a compelling choice Let's delve into...